Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kate Fitz's avatar

Thank you for this. I work downtown about 2 miles south of the protest areas and all is peaceful and quiet. I’m telling everyone that I feel safe walking around here because it is true!

Expand full comment
Bea Cardea's avatar

When we talk about this Big Ugly Bill we mostly focus on the impact it has on poor people, but we overlook that huge tax cuts to the wealthy impact all of us.

Here is an example:

- What if all public schools were equally resourced, meaning all the schools in the US were excellent, had nice buildings, better paid teachers, more course offerings, newer technology? Meaning, we did away with a system where local property wealth per capita gives advantage to the states’ richest school districts, (where some of them have sometimes 50 times more resources than other school districts!). What if we did not have to worry about our children’s future educational path the moment they are born? What if the most important task of a school was to help students find their passion, and to channel that passion into learning subjects better. What if every graduate of high school had a spot in a school at the next level waiting for them, whether academic or vocational, and what if the schools guaranteed that all youths under the age of 25 would be meaningfully occupied in either studies or employment?

- What would that cost? I looked at the budget of a well-resourced school district, one that has high property wealth, and I calculated that it allocates about $23,000 per student/per year. (My initial rough estimate - I need to finesse these calculations). This includes school bus expenses, some reserves for capital upgrades. There are about 48 million students K-12 in the public educational system. So, we would need about $1,116,000,000,000 to support all the students across our nation equally, giving all of them the same resources and opportunities as the students in a well-resourced district.

1 trillion+ dollars! Wow, can we afford this?!?! Sure, look at the proposed tax cuts for the wealthy, look at how the wealthiest and the corporations get away with not paying taxes! What's wrong in our country (and this Ugly Bill) is that we always choose to put money in the bank accounts of the wealthy and not in the 'We the People's' account.

NO MORE OF THAT. I think every parent should tell their legislators that they'll vote for them if they promise to make such a public school system vision a reality.

Next: what would a good healthcare system cost? what about affordable quality daycares across our nation? what about affordable higher education? what about dignified support for our elders?

YES WE CAN. WE ARE THE RICHEST NATION ON EARTH.

(What about my calculations? Any edits?)

Expand full comment
62 more comments...

No posts